The only duck egg frozen custard in the Finger Lakes

Churning ice cream is a Hoover family tradition. Starting when he was knee-high, Daniel learned the trade from his father. Now, teamed up with his wife Elizabeth, a long-term ice cream addict, the Hoover family has taken ice cream gourmet. First of all, ice cream wasn’t good enough, frozen custard was their bit. They both grew up on organic farms, so local and organic ingredients were a must. Along the same thought, nasty things like corn syrup and artificial flavors and colors were permanently banned. Then came the pivotal moment in history: the egg. They started with chicken, but decided to try duck and it blew everyone’s minds and taste buds! They started their own flock and never looked back. Now their Ancona ducks are the stars of the show and are responsible for the best tasting, local frozen custard that can be found.

From the Farm
Our ingredients are special. They are more than “run of the mill” milk and eggs. Here is why… Local Organic On Farm Real
Local- Most of our ingredients are sourced right in our neighborhood. With some products coming from the region and some from the backyard, we are supporting local economies and kicking our carbon footprint to the curb.Organic- Over 95% of our ingredients are either certified organic or grown following the same guidelines. What this means for you is the healthiest ice cream you can find that actually tastes good!
On Farm- We are proud to grow and raise a good amount of our ingredients right here at the Spotted Duck. Our lovely Ancona ducks supply us with delicious, rich eggs that make the creamiest custard, and our gardens provide us with delectable fruits that go from field to churn faster than you can say “ooh la la!” Come and sit by the pasture and say “Hello” to the ducks and other animals.Real- What do we mean by real? Real, as in, unadulterated honest-to-goodness ingredients. Ingredients like milk, sugar, eggs, cream, fruit and house-made vanilla. You won’t find any artificial colors, flavors, preservatives here. Corn syrup is banned from the property and hydrogenated oils are nowhere to be found. You can lick and slurp easy knowing that your sacred right to partake of “real” ice cream has been protected.

This picture is of our lovely ladies that provide the eggs that we use to make our delicious, one of a kind custard. Hence the name… Spotted Duck!


About Anconas
The Ancona is a hardy, adaptable, all-purpose duck. It is an excellent layer, typically laying 210-280 white, cream, or blue eggs yearly. This wonderful duck also grows relatively quickly, and produces high quality meat that is more flavorful and less fatty than that of most Pekin ducks. Anconas are well suited for situations where they can forage for some of their food and are capable of eating large banana slugs. They make excellent pond or yard ducks since they tend to stay close to home, do not fly under normal conditions and are large enough so that they are less likely to be preyed upon by winged predators. Typically they have moderately calm temperaments and make fine pets.

Ducks make a far superior custard than chicken eggs. The increased yolk size makes a much richer flavor while the firmer whites are a better suspender, giving our frozen custard it’s signature creamy texture.

999 State Route 54
Penn Yan, NY 14527

Social Media

Amenities and Services

– Handicap Accessible
– Real Farm Experience